Skip to Content

Mega Epic Insider’s Guide to the Best Bagels in Brooklyn Right Now!

Come with me as we frollic into a land of carb-o-rific bliss – a place that can only be found by devouring the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Because while we all know that New York City serves up THE best bagels in the world (not up for debate), what you might not know us where to find them.

And if you should find yourself in the very hipster paradise that is Brooklyn, stop for a sec and appreciate this burrough’s culinary awesomeness by checking out all the best bagel shops in Brooklyn.

After all, I’m a 30+ year local who knows exactly where the best bagel places in Brooklyn are hidden.

So, if you’re more than a little confused about there to get your foodie swerve on then continue onwards my friend as we dive into this list of the best Brooklyn bagels of all time.

This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure for more information. As an Amazon Associate, I earn a small commission from qualifying purchases.

Where to Stay in Brooklyn

Honestly, Brooklyn is expensive AF. Therefore, it can difficult to find a nice place to stay that is both reasonably priced and well-located.

Thankfully, though, this savvy local is here to help make your life a whole lot easier.

Because regardless of your budget, Brooklyn really does have the perfect hotel for you – and this list will help you find that place right now.

  • Aloft New York Brooklyn (Budget) – Well-priced rooms at Aloft New York Brooklyn will feel uber-fancy, just without the high price tag. So, expect to be near the subway and to enjoy rooms with flat-screen TVs, ergonomic chairs, and walk-in showers. You’ll also love the indoor pool and the impressive rooftop bar.

Best Bagels in Brooklyn – Cobble Hill

1. Court Street Bagels

Bagel with lox and cream cheese that is known for being the best bagels in Brooklyn

Starting strong with a firm favorite among Brooklynites, Court Street Bagels is an unassuming neighborhood bagel spot where all products are baked fresh on the premises.

So, choose between multigrain or sourdough with a blend of beloved flavors including garlic, sesame, and onion.

You’ll also love that bagels here are thick and fluffy with a slightly firm shell – exactly as New York bagels are meant to be!

However, on top of the sheer variety of bagels on offer, Court Street Bagels also has an exemplary selection of cream cheeses. In fact, their walnut raisin comes highly recommended.

The deli also rustles up equally delectable sandwiches, in addition to a small egg-based breakfast menu, and a token offering of sweet treats.

And since this place opens daily at 6:00 am, these are some of the best bagels in Brooklyn for early risers staying locally and seeking swift counter service.

You also can’t miss this spot since the scent of freshly-baked bagels gently wafts down Court Street.

Just be aware that this joint only has one or two tables. So, you should expect to get your order to go.

They’re also cash only. So, come prepared. Fortunately, though, the bagels here are extremely affordable and servers do not scrimp on fillings for the best Brooklyn bagels of all time.

Address: 181 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States

Hours: Open daily from 6:00 am to 5:00 pm.

Price: Sammies start at $6.75 each.

How to Get There: Take the 2/3 train to Borough Hall and walk from there.

2. Shelsky’s of Brooklyn Appetizing and Delicatessen

Easily one of the best bagel places in Brooklyn. Shelsky’s of Brooklyn Appetizing and Delicatessen is the byproduct of a beautiful collaboration between ultra-fab New Yorkers, Peter Shelsky, and Lewis Spada.

As a result, the deli menu and pantry items at the store are loyal to the food that both men ate throughout their childhood.

Therefore, you’ll find pastrami salmon, house-cured pastrami, corned beef, and beef tongue all on the menu at one of the best bagel shops in Brooklyn.

And then there are the bagels, which are made using traditional Jewish baking techniques that result in the ideal balance of a dense/chewy interior with a slightly crisp exterior.

In particular, though, fish bagels are all the rage at Shelsky’s and are created using smoked whitefish and pickled herring for a satisfying and filling lunch. Pastrami is a big fan favorite too for anyone looking for the best bagels in Brooklyn.

However, seating is limited to a couple of stools by the window. So, it’s best if you grab your bagel to go.

But, don’t just visit Shelsky’s of Brooklyn for the bagels. Instead, take some time to browse through the shelves and stock up on spreads, pickles, and knishes too.

Pro Tip: In addition to their Cobble Hill deli, Shelsky’s also has a bagel joint in Park Slope.

Address: 141 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States

Hours: Open daily from 8:00 am to 4:00 pm.

Price: Bagels start at $1.80 each.

How to Get There: Take the 2/3/4/5 train to Borough Hall and walk from there.

3. Smith Street Bagels

Bagels on a plate from one of the best bagel shops in Brooklyn.

Smith Street Bagels have been busy baking the best bagels in Brooklyn for the past decade.

And what stands out about this Cobble Hill bagel place is the “pizza bagel” menu. That’s right: bagels dressed in all your favorite pizza toppings!

So, take your pick from their classic margarita or peruse through their vegan pizza bagel offerings instead, which include plant-based cheese and almond parmesan.

On the other hand, bagel enthusiasts that can’t resist the call of lox can cast their eye over to a menu dedicated to this fishy classic.

Plus, beyond bagels, this is one of the best bagel shops in Brooklyn that delights diners with all-day breakfast, crisp build-your-own salads, and sugary desserts.

Then, wash it all down with a creamy iced coffee or a nutrient-packed smoothie or juice blended right before your eyes and you’ll have a meal to remember from one of the best bagel shops in Brooklyn.

The interiors are also super laid-back with a sprinkling of seating indoors as well as a few benches on the sidewalk.

Pro Tip: They even have rainbow bagels on the menu if you’re looking for something super Instagrammable.

Address: 202 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States

Hours: Open daily from 6:00 am to 5:00 pm.

Price: $12.00 for 7 bagels and cream cheese.

How to Get There: Take the F train to Bergen Street station and walk from there.

Best Bagels in Brooklyn – Prospect Heights

4. Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe

Best bagels in Brooklyn on a wooden table.

Founded in 2010, Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe is a vintage-style bagel place that bakes its bagels using old-school techniques.

As is mandatory for creating the best bagels in Brooklyn, bagels are baked on the premises. That means the delicious aromas from the kitchen hit you the moment you step inside one of the best bagel shops in Brooklyn.

And spearheaded by their signature “everything” bagel, the menu here is vast with lox and your cream cheese of choice being a solid starting place.

From time to time, you can even pick up rainbow bagels at Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe. A surefire way to brighten your day and your social media feed in one fell swoop.

Additionally, their coffee deserves a special mention since It’s full of flavor and will fire you up for a day of exploring. Plus, if you want, you can even buy a bag to take home with you.

Now, unlike most of the best bagel places in Brooklyn, Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe has a decent amount of seating both indoors and out on the patio.

Plus, the ambiance here is just kind of special. So, it’s advisable to nab a table if there’s one free. But, you can always get your bagels and coffee to go if you prefer.

So, just order at the counter where you’ll see daily offerings stacked behind the cash register. This place is also cash only but the cafe does have an ATM on site.

Address: 645 Vanderbilt Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238, United States

Hours: Open daily from 7:00 am to 5:00 pm.

Price: Bagel with lox and cream cheese is $8.00.

How to Get There: Take the Q train to 7th Avenue and walk from there.

5. Bergen Bagels

After relocating to New York from Israel, Yitzhak Saadi founded the original Bergen Bagels in 1999. So, in addition to the Bergen Street deli, you’ll also find two other outposts in Clinton Hill.

Now, Bergen Bagels offers counter service and is a takeaway-only joint that remains busy around the clock.

And that’s mostly because fresh bagels are crafted in true New York style with a pillowy interior and a crisp outer bite.

Then, large swathes of golden rolls fresh from the oven flood the racks behind the counter and are ready for you to dive into at one of the best bagel shops in Brooklyn.

Meanwhile, an extensive menu of cream cheeses awaits you and includes a large selection of both sweet and savory varieties.

So, choose between avocado, feta, blueberry, and lox (which you can double up with a topping of that tasty fish) to start off with.

Just come hungry since these best bagels in Brooklyn are huge and come adorned with a generous amount of cream cheese too.

Therefore, expect to get at least two meals out of your order from one of the best bagel shops in Brooklyn.

Address: 473 Bergen St, Brooklyn, NY 11217, United States

Hours: Open daily from 6:00 am to 6:00 pm.

Price: Between $2.00 and $3.00 each for a bagel with your fave spread.

How to Get There: Take the 2/3 train to Bergen Street station and walk from there.

Best Bagels in Brooklyn – Bushwick

6. Knickerbocker Bagels

Rack of bagels from one of the best bagel shops in Brooklyn.

Knickerbocker Bagels whips up hand-rolled, water-boiled bagels with a satisfying crunch that easily qualifies this as one of the best bagel shops in Brooklyn.

Plus, available options are almost never-ending and include every seed you can imagine as well as egg, pumpernickel, and English muffin varieties.

However, the pastrami/salmon adorned bagels come up tops here. But, if you’re in the mood for something sweet, the strawberry spread is to die for.

Then, beyond the best bagels in Brooklyn, Knickerbocker Bagels also offers wraps, omelets, and baked treats. You can also check their counter for “medicinal” chocolate flavored with healthy foods like pink salt and goji berries.

Additionally, the coffee on offer here caters to fans of froth and those who favor American-style beverages.

Plus, this is one of the best bagel shops in Brooklyn that features a gigantic range of refreshing soft drinks that include sodas, juices, waters, and more.

Then, when you’re ready to dig in, just place your order with the cashier and enjoy sufficient seating if you’d like to dine in.

And with high ceilings that are perfectly complimented by stunning brickwork, Knickerbocker Bagels offers patrons an idyllic atmosphere to dine within.

Also, the staff here are notoriously friendly and patient – even when rushed by large crowds of eager diners. So, it’s no small wonder that this bagel shop tops numerous lists of the best bagels in Brooklyn for its quality of food, pricing, and impeccable service!

Address: 367 Knickerbocker Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11237, United States

Hours: Open daily from 7:00 am to 3:00 pm.

Price: A bagel with cream cheese is $3.95.

How to Get There: Take the L train to DeKalb Avenue and walk from there.

Best Bagels in Brooklyn – Crown Heights

7. Bagel Pub

Bagel Pub is a New York franchise with four locations across Brooklyn and two in Manhattan.

And the Crown Heights outpost tops the list of the best bagels in Brooklyn with its sleek interiors and fantastic outdoor seating.

They also offer delicious, freshly baked bagels that are piled high behind the counter and that come generously slathered in a variety of cream cheeses and other toppings that are presented to you behind a glass display case.

When in doubt though, snap up one of their ​​epic pumpernickel bags with lox. And if you want, you can savor this fish on its own or sample it with some avocado and pastrami.

However, if you’re a total veg, not to worry because Bagel Pub has a fabulous range of vegetarian fillings too.

Additionally, Bagel Pub excels at serving up incredible fresh squeezed juices that can be paired with a shot of immunity-boosting wheatgrass or ginger.

So, feel free to order online for pick-up or directly at the counter. And if you’re having a party, bags of bagels are sold by the pound and can then be brought back to your place for eating.

The one downside of Bagel Pub? There’s nearly always a line. But, that’s the price you pay for some of the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Address: 775 Franklin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238, United States

Hours: Open daily from 8:30 am to 2:30 pm.

Price: $2.00 for a bagel with cream cheese.

How to Get There: Take the 2/3 train to Franklin Av-Medgar Evers College station and walk from there.

Best Bagels in Brooklyn – Williamsburg

8. Bagelsmith

Bagels with spread from one of the best bagel places in Brooklyn.

Bagelsmith is a duo of low-key counters that continually pump out some of the best homemade bagels and deli sandwiches in Williamsburg.

Both are mellow, neighborhood diners with friendly staff who fare well with the long lines each bagel store attracts.

In particular, Bagelsmith is responsible for some of the best bagels in Brooklyn for vegans.

Yeah, they have a super olid line-up of tofu-based and vegan-friendly spreads. Plus, the tofu lox spread is handy for non-vegans that are sensitive to lactose.

The coffee is also top-notch, although this place really is a tea drinkers paradise too. After all, the menu has a wide variety of offerings inclduing herbal, green, and black tea options.

Be aware though that their Bedford Avenue store has limited window seating but a cute, Instagrammable facade.

On the other hand, the branch on Lorimer Street is takeout only. So, you can order online for pickup or delivery – or place your order directly at the counter in person at one of the best bagel places in Brooklyn.

Address: 189 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211, United States

Hours: Open daily from 7:00 am to 5:00 pm, with extended hours until 6:00 pm on Fridays and Saturdays.

Price: Bagels with cream cheese start at $5.75 each.

How to Get There: Take the L train to Bedford Avenue and walk from there.

Best Bagel Shops in Brooklyn – Brooklyn Heights

9. Montague Street Bagels

Montague Street Bagels is a chill deli and bagel place in the heart of Brooklyn Heights. Prices are also reasonable and the cafe offers a ton of weekday lunch promos and free coffee packages.

Plus, with long hours and an economical price point, Montague Street Bagels is popular with locals.

Addtitionally, cold cuts are sourced from Boar’s Head and paired with your chosen cream cheese of choice.

Actually, the amount of cream cheese you get is almost on par with the width of the bread. So, if you like your bagels heavy on cream cheese then this is one of the best bagel places in Brooklyn for you.

And in addition to bagels, Montague Street Bagels excels at salads, sandwiches, and wraps.

You’ll also love that there are a small cluster of tables out front. However, as with most bagel joints in Brooklyn, seating is limited so you might have to grab your bagel to go.

Address: 108 Montague St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States

Hours: Open daily from 6:00 am to 9:00 pm, with extended hours until 10:00 pm on Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays.

Price: $2.08 for a bagel with cream cheese.

How to Get There: Take the N/R train to Court Street and walk from there.

Best Bagel Places in Brooklyn – Downtown

10. Pio Bagel

Artisinal bagels from one of the best bagel shops in Brooklyn.

Head to Pio Bagel for the best bagels in downtown Brooklyn.

After all, this epic family-owned business is run by four siblings who relocated to NYC from Ecuador in the 1990s.

Then, soon after arriving in the country, the Espinoza family was (well, naturally) captivated by New York’s bagel scene. They then decided to open their own bagel place – but with a Latin twist.

Incidentally, this is the same family that owns Tio Pio.

So, bagels span the classics in addition to those iconic rainbow bagels that have taken over everyone’s Instagram feed.

However, their signature bagel fuses cheddar cheese, bacon, and onions together to create the ultimate carb-o-rific delight.

Plus, they have a rad selection of lox, salmon, and whitefish if you’re looking for some omega-3s to pair with some of the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Now, this popular bagel shop in Brooklyn occupies a prominent spot at the junction of Lawrence Street and Willoughby Street and is rarely seen without a line.

Plus, there’s no seating. So, remember to wear your sneakers and grab your bagel and a fresh squeezed juice to go.

Address: 136 Lawrence St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States

Hours: Open daily from 6:00 am to 2:00 pm, with reduced hours until 1:00 pm on Saturdays and Sundays.

Price: Bagels start at $2.80 each.

How to Get There: Take the A/F to Jay Street station and walk from there.

Best Bagel Shops in Brooklyn – DUMBO

11. Bread and Spread

Planning an early morning jaunt to Pebble Beach? If so then start your day the right way with a trip to Bread and Spread.

After all, this hipster bagel cafe in DUMBO specializes in artisanal bagels and other toasted breads that are made using nothing but the highest-quality ingredients.

And if you’re a fan of salty meats, do try their porchetta. It’s pretty light in texture and bursting with flavor that you’ll won’t forget in a hurry.

Or, on the off chance that you’re hankering after something besides the best bagels in Brooklyn, try the bánh mì instead.

it’s prepared with fresh strips of cucumber, pickled daikon, and jalapenos, making it’s the bee’s knees when it comes to epic sammies.

Plus, there are a couple of tables inside where you can watch the baristas at work. Or, take a seat out front if you want to soak up the atmosphere of Front Street as you eat.

Otherwise, you can take your bagel and coffee down to the river and enjoy it with the Manhattan skyline in the background.

Address: 151 Front St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States

Hours: Open daily from 8:00 am to 5:30 pm.

Price: $5.00 each for breakfast sandwiches.

How to Get There: Take the F train to Jay Street and walk from there.

Best Bagel Places in Brooklyn – Bedford-Stuyvesant

12. Greenberg’s Bagels

Greenberg’s Bagels rustle up some of the best bagels in Brooklyn for breakfast.

And there’s no better way to start your Sunday than with a bacon, egg, and cheese combo. And the only way it gets better is if you add an order of hash browns on the side!

What, not a meat-eater? If so then go for the vegan equivalent of the B.E.C.

But, for something lighter, try some tofu cream cheese smeared on top of one of their supremely toasted bagels.

Yeah, the style of Greenburg’s will totally suit you if you like a bit of crunch and texture to your baked goods.

You can so things the New Yorker way and get a coffee to go alongside with your Greenberg bagel.

And, added bonus? This is one of the best bagel shops in Brooklyn that also sells deli sandwiches and several cakes if you fancy a bit of dessert after your brekkie bagel.

Due to the humble size of this place though, this Bed-Stuy bagel joint is takeout only. However, you can always online via their website or Instagram profile for pick-up/delivery.

Address: 1065 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216, United States

Hours: Open daily from 8:00 am to 6:00 pm.

Price: A bagel with cream cheese starts at $4.50.

How to Get There: Take the G train to Bedford – Nostrand Avenue station and walk from there.

Best Bagel Shops in Brooklyn – Coney Island

13. Bagel Boy

Bagel with cream cheese from one of the best bagel shops in Brooklyn.

Bagel Boy prides itself for making world-class bagels, sandwiches, soups, and salads.

And ingredients here cover the classics like cold cuts, with some veggie alternatives. All available ingredients and toppings are also presented you on the counter so that you can go where your tummy guides you.

On the other hand, Bagel Boy is one of the best bagel stores in Brooklyn for larger groups. In fact, they offer various family and super-sized platters that’ll feed up to 25 people.

However, there is limited seating at Bagel Boy. And since the bagel counter is located in a general store, it’s best to grab some of the best Brooklyn bagels to go.

Also, in addition to the Coney Island location, Bagel Boy has a second establishment in Bay Ridge.

So, if that first bite is enough to convert you, then you might want to download the Bagel Boy app to stay ahead of additions to the menu and order while on the go.

Address: 2829 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11235, United States

Hours: Open daily from 5:00 am to 5:00 pm.

Price: Starts at $3.25 for a plain bagel with cream cheese.

How to Get There: Take the Q to Sheepshead Bay and walk from there.

Best Bagel Places in Brooklyn – Park Slope

14. Bagel Hole

Founded in 1985, longtimer Bagel Hole is one of the OG destinations for the best bagels in Brooklyn.

And to this day they remain committed to crafting hand-rolled bagels with the finest ingredients, free from preservatives and additives.

Therefore, all their bagels are stuffed to bursting with premium cold cuts, freshly prepped salad items, or Bagel Hole’s famous whitefish.

Meanwhile, cream cheese spreads are intensely flavored with scallions, walnuts and raisins, lox, and basically anything else you can imagine.

And while choices here are less vast, every item on the menu is supremely well-crafted.

However, what’s truly unique about Bagel Hole is that they don’t toast the bagels. As turnover is so fast, your order always arrives fresh out of the oven, so no toasting required!

And that’s good since toast free is the way to be in New York.

Addtionally, Bagel Hole sits insdie one of the fetching brownstones that Park Slope is known for. As a result though, it’s a tiny little hole in the wall place with counter service and takeout only.

But, fear not because they serve coffee too.

Address: 400 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, United States

Hours: Open dally from 7:00 am to 3:00 pm.

Price: $2.39 for a bagel with cream cheese.

How to Get There: Take the F/G train to 7th Avenue and walk from there.

15. Terrace Bagels

Situated near the southwest corner of Prospect Park, Terrace Bagels is your one-stop shop for refueling after a morning stroll.

After all, savory and sweet bagels are accompanied by your choice of toppings that include peanut butter, jelly, and lox.

Meat-based ingredients are also available and sourced from the everybody’s favorite deli supplier, Boar’s Head.

However, one of the niftiest things about Terrace Bagels is that you get to pick between regular and mini bagels. So, these are some of the best bagels in Brooklyn if you a) want to eat light, or b) want to sample two or more varieties of bagels!

And while all the bagels here are good, their “everything” bagel with an egg is a real knockout. Plus, it comes with protein, making it a tid bit healthier…maybe!

But, aside from the bagels, Terrace Bagels also serves up all sorts of sandwiches, wraps, and baked goods.

Plus, this is one of the top picks for the best bagels in Brooklyn for dining in since there are a ton of tables inside as well as several on the sidewalk – ideal for a messy bagel on a quiet Sunday morning.

Address: 222 &, 222A Prospect Park West, 11215, United States

Hours: Open daily from 7:00 am to 4:00 pm.

Price: $9.00 for bagel with lox, tomatoes, and cream cheese.

How to Get There: Take the F/G train to Prospect Park and walk from there.

16. Bagel World

Bagel World is seriously popular and once you step inside and get a whiff of what’s behind the counter you’ll see why!

Because these are some of the best bagels in Brooklyn that are baked on-site and that come with a mix of standard and eclectic fillings.

So, besides your classic lox, pastrami, and turkey, you can opt for chicken curry and juicy shrimp salad on top of your bagel of choice.

And bagel flavors fo span the gambit, including rainbow bagels.

But, don’t leave Bagel World without grabbing a donut for after. Yup, these tasty little nigget of delights are slathered with chocolate and cream and pair perfectly with a cappuccino.

Bagel World also has a cute window where you can order without having to step inside, which is awesome for anyone with a dog or a stroller!

And if you do want to dine in, the cafe has a compact seating area where you can nibble on your bagel and enjoy the homey atmosphere one of the best bagel shops in Brooklyn.

Address: 339 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, United States

Hours: Open daily from 6:00 am to 6:00 pm.

Price: $3.75 for a bagel with cream cheese.

How to Get There: Take the F train to 7th Avenue and walk from there.

17. La Bagel Delight

Bagel with lox and cream cheese from one of the best bagel places in Brooklyn.

Wrapping up this guide to the best bagels in Brooklyn is a place you need to add to your list – especially if you’re looking for the best brunch in Brooklyn.

Because La Bagel Delight has been one of the best bagel shops in Brooklyn since 1986 and has five locations scattered throughout the borough.

And to me is a solid stamp of approval from the residents!

Now, besides two spots in Park Slope, you’ll find outposts in DUMBO, Fort Greene, and Cobble Hill too.

And that’s mainly because bagels here are prepared the old-fashioned way and served with a killer selection of spreads such as apple cinnamon, scallion, and tofu blended cream cheese.

This place also gets extra credit since their outer crust is always spot-on and requires no toasting.

Prices are also reasonable, particularly when you see how committed the staff are to stuffing your bagel with your chosen filling. Coffee is also served piping hot and is celebrated for its eye-opening strength – making this a possible contender for one of the best Brooklyn coffee shops.

Their 284 7th Avenue joint also has a couple of seats at the rear of the restaurant but offer takeaway and delivery as well if no spots are available.

Address: 284 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, United States

Hours: Open daily from 5:30 am to 6:00 pm, with limited hours until 4:00 pm on Saturday and Sunday.

Price: $5.25 for a bagel with cream cheese.

How to Get There: Take the F/G train to 7th Avenue and walk from there.

Map of the Best Bagel Places in Brooklyn

Map of the best bagel places in Brooklyn.
Click here for the full map.

Additional Brooklyn Resources You’ll Love

There you have it! That wraps up this epic guide to the best bagel places in Brooklyn.

Tell me, did your picks for the best bagel shops in Brooklyn make the list? If not then let me know in the comments below.

And if you found this post useful don’t foegt to join our email list before pinning this post now so that you can read it again later.