Planning a supremely romantic weekend getaway with your partner? If so then you need this list of the most romantic hotels on Long Island in your life.
Trust me, I grew up going out to Long Island almost every weekend. And between the sick restaurants, stunning vineyards, and beautiful beaches, it’s easily one of the most romantic destinations in the state.
However, when planning a Long Island romantic getaway it can be hard to know where to stay to really set the mood and create a truly beautiful vacation.
Well, luckily for you I’m a 30+ year local who understands where to go to enjoy the best couples getaway Long Island has to offer so that you can enjoy the best bakeries in Long Island too.
So, take my advice and check out my top picks for the most romantic hotels on Long Island now.
This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure for more information. As an Amazon Associate, I earn a small commission from qualifying purchases.
Short on time? ⏰ Then book a room at The Menhaden Hotel. The staff is lovely and the rooftop is incredible, making this the best and most romantic hotel on Long Island.?
Romantic hotels on Long Island – Luxury
1. Oheka Castle and Estate
⭐️ Rating: 9.0/10.0 (484 Reviews) Price: $355 per night ?Location: 135 W Gate Dr, Huntington, NY 11743 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
Naturally, historic Oheka Castle is one of the most romantic hotels on Long Island for a special occasion.
After all, you can’t get more romantic than sleeping in one of the grandest castles in New York now, can you?
In fact, this estate is surrounded by formal gardens and is a luxe chateau-style building in Huntington that makes for a popular wedding venue.
“Beautiful estate, restored to its former glory! Very comfortable bed, it was peaceful & quiet, and the bathroom was amazing. Also, vaulted ceiling in the room with a sky light.”Cory (read more reviews now)
Plus, it’s regularly featured in movies and is a high-end retreat for lots of A-list celebs.
Then, once you step inside you’ll find elegant rooms outfitted with Frette linens and period piece furniture.
Meanwhile, private bathrooms are stocked with Molton Brown products.
And if you’re looking for a bit of a splurge – or value your space – check out the suites, which pay homage to the likes of Gatsby and Andrew Carnegie.
But, since taking handheld strolls around this gorgeous estate is tiring work, you’ll be pleased to hear that the on-site restaurant knocks it out of the park with various fusion European and American dishes.
Just be aware that reservations are required for lunch and dinner.
|Breakfast included||No pool or spa|
|Pet-friendly||Some rooms lack natural light|
|Unique environment and architecture|
|Perfect for an anniversary/proposal|
2. Mill House Inn
⭐️ Rating: 8.0/10.0 (44 Reviews) Price: $250 per night ?Location: 31 N Main St, East Hampton, NY 11937 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
Located in fancy AF East Hampton, Mill House Inn is a short drive (or bike ride) from some of the best beaches in the Hamptons.
Therefore, if you and your partner love windswept wanders, this is one of the best romantic hotels on Long Island for you.
Awesome for quirkier peeps, each of the 10 rooms and suites at this boutique hotel is uniquely decorated.
Plus, most units feature a fireplace while suites come fully equipped with kitchenettes. Furthermore, the top-tier suites feature two-person bathtubs too for added romance.
“Spent my birthday here after arriving from Australia. Felt like I was in a movie and one of my wishes had come true staying in an historic Inn in the Hamptons. The Inn and grounds are beautiful and we were completely spoilt by Kelli who was inconspicuous yet so attentive to our questions and requests. The suite was stunning and the bed and bedding were exceptionally comfy and luxe. We felt like we had the place to ourselves and had afternoon cocktails on the porch watching the sunset and the windmill before heading to a beautiful restaurant in Sag Harbour for dinner.”Helen (read more reviews now)
Heck, you’ll even have “Personal Assistants” at your disposal to help you plan organic picnics, make restaurant recommendations, or hook you up with a sunset cruise in Sag Harbor.
Bringing a little one away on your Long Island romantic getaway? Well, then the staff here can even set you up with a trusted babysitter.
However, whatever you do, don’t skip the lobster rolls at breakfast. In fact, everything served at Gary’s Restaurant is locally sourced from nearby farms and bakers and absolutely delicious.
Plus, if you plan to visit during the summer, breakfast is served in the lush garden. Yup, #amazing.
|Intimate, boutique atmosphere||No lunch or dinner is available|
|Breakfast included||Some rooms could use some maintenance|
|Staff to help with booking local activities|
3. The Baker House 1650
⭐️ Rating: 9.5/10.0 (30 Reviews) Price: $285 per night ?Location: 181 Main St, East Hampton, NY 11937 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
Championing simple yet casual luxury, the Baker House 1650 is one of the most romantic hotels on Long Island for a spa weekend.
Because amenities here include an indoor counter-current heated pool (available year-round), a Jacuzzi tub, a dry sauna, and a eucalyptus steam shower.
Plus, what makes it all the more luxurious is that only two guests may access the facilities at any given time.
Yup, that’s right – your own private sanctuary during your Long Island romantic getaway.
“Exceeded our expectations. Our stay was so much fun and we really enjoyed breakfast in bed every morning during our stay. Would definitely recommend the baker house!”Devendra (read more reviews now)
Meanwhile, the outdoor infinity-edge pool overlooks the lawn, wisteria, and English-style gardens.
Then, in summer, you can make use of the sun loungers and get a fresh dose of vitamin D.
And while some rooms are appointed with William Morris wallpaper and fabrics – adding a rustic-chic vibe – others feature wood paneling, original wood beams, and open fireplaces.
Also, to add to the ambiance, a couple of rooms are fitted with window seats – perfect for canoodling and daydreaming – while suites come with deep soaking tubs.
Therefore, just be sure to do your research so that you can find the perfect room for you during a magical couples getaway Long Island.
|Luxury spa and two pools on-site||No pets allowed|
|Free parking||Some rooms are small-ish|
|One-of-a-kind rooms and suites to suit all tastes||Rooms overlooking the main road can get noisy|
|Breakfast is included with the option to dine in the room|
4. The Quogue Club
⭐️ Rating: 9.1/10.0 (28 Reviews) Price: $295 per night ?Location: 47 Quogue St, Quogue, NY 11959 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
Located in the Quogue Historic District, the Quogue Club is a short bike ride from some of the most pristine Long Island Beaches of them all.
Furthermore, you can walk to many of the best restaurants, boutiques, and galleries in Quogue.
See, this stunning boutique hotel offers five-star accommodations that are brought to you by the world-renowned designer, Alexa Hampton.
So, contemporary rooms are styled with minimalist interiors in soothing color palettes that are inspired by the sea and sand dunes. Plus, luxury bathing products await you in your private en-suite bathroom.
“The hotel is beautiful and comfortable. staff were lovely and helpful. we felt like it was a home away from home.”Corina (read more reviews now)
However, if you need more space you can cocoon yourself away in the Cottage.
Then, throughout your stay, you’ll enjoy access to the private social and dining club. Here, you can sink your teeth into fresh, local fare and swirl top-notch wines from some of the best vineyards in Long Island.
Furthermore, you can get your daily dose of wellness at the fitness center or yoga studio. In fact, the hotel also has a partnership with a local tennis club that offers a mix of indoor and outdoor courts.
On the other hand, the concierge can schedule in-room couples massages.
Pro Tip: Although epic for a romantic escape, the Quogue Club is known for its family-friendly spirit.
|Passes are provided to access the private beach||Pets are not allowed|
|Spa and fitness facilities on-site||Rooms lack personality|
|Free use of bicycles|
5. The Montauk Beach House
⭐️ Rating: 8.4/10.0 (74 Reviews) Price: $409 per night ?Location: 55 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk, NY 11954 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
Hip and happening, the Montauk Beach House has an epic atmosphere that’ll appeal to sociable travelers.
So, in addition to the outdoor pool, the complex features a communal space where you can mingle with other guests.
Now, rooms are divided into three categories with options to suit both couples and families.
Plus, most units come with a private patio or balcony, with the option to upgrade to a pool-view room.
“The room was great – beds and pillows were super comfortable. The pool area was amazing- music and waitress service by the pool were an added bonus.”Melissa (read more reviews now)
In particular, the Moonlight Rooms are appealing to couples since they feature paneled walls and vintage lighting that creates a unique ambiance. Plus, the freestanding claw-foot tubs add a touch of decadence.
And since this place is well-located near various local beaches, this Montauk property is one of the romantic hotels on Long Island for couples who love to surf.
Also, their restaurant serves up grills and light bites that’ll keep your stamina up. Meanwhile, the cocktails are shaken and stirred to perfection.
Pro-Tip: Get the waves early before the crowds arrive and then head back to the hotel for a lazy afternoon by the pool.
|Close to Montauk’s best beaches||Limited availability when it comes to pet-friendly rooms|
|Swimming pool||Not all rooms have a fridge|
|Balcony rooms available||Parking is free but limited|
|Poolside cocktail service|
Romantic hotels on Long Island – Midrange
6. The Menhaden Hotel
⭐️ Rating: 9.4/10.0 (104 Reviews) Price: $209 per night ?Location: 207 Front St, Greenport, NY 11944 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
A newcomer to the romantic hotels on the Long Island scene, the Menhaden Hotel is a glamorous 4-star property.
Here, all rooms and suites are stylishly appointed with Restoration Hardware furnishings and lavish high-thread count linens.
All rooms also have big windows to allow for plenty of natural light, while certain units offer partial views of Greenport Harbor.
Meanwhile, spa-like bathrooms come with either a bathtub or a shower.
“The hotel is beautifully designed, exceptionally clean, ample snacks, beverages available free of charge, but the absolute standout is the staff/service. Within moments of reserving our room, i received a text from the property welcoming us and offering their services. Their suggestions, assistance were outstanding!!!!! Rooftop deck is wonderful!!!!!!”Olena (read more reviews now)
Furthermore, with a grand total of 16 rooms to choose from, this boutique hotel feels intimate and creates a peaceful place for your Long Island romantic getaway.
Although there are no fridges in individual rooms, each floor of the hotel has a small kitchen where you can store essentials.
Additionally, you’ll find a supply of treats and a light daily breakfast available in those kitchens, so dig in and help yourself.
Plus, you’re welcome to hang out on the rooftop terrace with a bar, lounge seating, and fire pits: s’mores, anyone?
Also be sure to chat with lobby staff about curated wine tastings, picnics, and tours.
|Free parking||Pricey for a mid-range hotel|
|New hotel that feels fresh||Basic rooms have no dining room table and chairs|
|Complimentary bike rentals|
7. Journey East Hampton
⭐️ Rating: 8.1/10.0 (114 Reviews) Price: $205 per night ?Location: 490 Pantigo Rd, East Hampton, NY 11937 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
Halfway between the villages of East Hampton and Amagansett sits Journey East Hampton.
In fact, this spot is a 20-minute drive from Montauk and is a quaint hotel that expertly balances country charm with modern-day luxury.
See, the decor is super cute and has a nautical theme, with landscape paintings on the walls and funky tile work in the bathrooms.
Rooms, studios, and cottages are also generously outfitted with Frette linens and towels as well as luxury bath products.
“This was our second time at Journey, and it was just as great as we remembered! We love the close proximity to Moby’s, and access to the bikes to bike down to the beach. The reception staff was lovely to interact with, and very helpful.”Corey (read more reviews now)
Then, in addition to the in-room mini fridge, you’ll have access to a grab-and-go breakfast. This is laid out fresh each morning in the lobby for you to enjoy in your room or during a picnic by the beach.
Now. out in the backyard you can cool down in the saltwater pool and relax beneath the sun on the spacious lawn. Because various trees and shrubs create a lovely sense of privacy.
Plus, there is usually a ready supply of yard games here in the summer months.
Another neat touch are the fire pits that are lit in the evenings to create an ultra-romantic campsite atmosphere.
|Free bike rentals||Expensive|
|Seasonal saltwater pool||No pets allowed|
|Nightly fire pit with s’mores||Check-in is after 4:00 pm|
|Beach towels offered||Rooms can get noisy because of traffic on a nearby road|
8. Harbor Rose Bed and Breakfast
⭐️ Rating: 9.3/10.0 (71 Reviews) Price: $258 per night ?Location: 253 Harbor Rd #25A, Cold Spring Harbor, NY 11724 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
Owned by a mother-daughter duo, checking in at the Harbor Rose Bed and Breakfast is like staying with family.
Furthermore, the space has been designed to create a sense of balance. So, any stress you have will almost instantly melt away.
Plus, since this place is located in Cold Spring Harbor, rooms at this historic manor house come with either a sea or garden view.
And while there are only three rooms available at this B&B, each is individually styled and affixed to a private bathroom.
Therefore, you’ll need to get organized and book ahead to avoid disappointment.
In particular, The Victorian King has a fireplace, balcony, and harbor view. Sure, the views are best during winter, but you can still see the water through the foliage come summer.
“The property is located on a part of Harbor Road that faces the inner harbor of Cold Spring Harbor and the view is absolutely breathtaking. The house and room are beautiful and spacious. The staff is superb! Violetta was phenomenal!!”Danielle (read more reviews now)
Plus, this room gives you a front-row seat at golden hour, aka sunset.
Breakfast is also included and made fresh with organic, plant-based ingredients. So, if you’re looking for romantic hotels on Long Island for vegans, this is the place for you.
And the best thing about this B&B? You’ll be greeted by Prince, a hypoallergenic Moyan Poodle! Can I get a woot woot? LOL.
|A homey environment, yet the privacy of guests is respected||Very limited availability – not suitable for spontaneous couples|
|Great home-cooked vegan food||Sensitive sleepers might hear traffic noise|
|Friendly dog on-site and property dog-friendly|
9. Haven Montauk
⭐️ Rating: 8.6/10.0 (608 Reviews) Price: $145 per night ?Location: 533 W Lake Dr, Montauk, NY 11954 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
Situated on the northern shore of Lake Montauk, Haven Montauk is within walking distance of Sunset Beach.
It’s also a boutique motel that consists of 27 crisply appointed contemporary studios and apartments.
Louvered shutters add to the vacation vibe, and – almost – whisk you away to the tropics.
Now, while all units have a private bathroom, you will need to specify at the time you make your reservation whether you prefer a tub or shower.
“Everything was simple and good. They take care of the things that I value. A clean and comfortable bed, a coffee maker (with good coffee) a fridge. Near the bay (ocean is close by). Yogurt and light snacks available, bikes, shampoo, etc. Didnt have to worry about a thing!”Jennifer (read more reviews now)
And remember, if you want your own kitchen from which to whip up a romantic dinner, you’ll need to book one of their apartments.
Yeah, these also have a lounge for cozy Netflix nights at one of the most romantic hotels on Long Island.
Furthermore, you can select a sunset view room if you’d rather catch golden hour from the comfort of your bed.
And in terms of getting around, this motel offers free bike rental and complimentary beach passes for Ditch Park.
Plus, there’s no need to hit the beach for a swim since Haven Montauk has its own open-air pool where you can do some daily laps.
|Pet-friendly||Could do with minor maintenance|
|Free Parking||No bar and the breakfast offering is very basic|
|Outdoor Seasonal Pool|
|Coffee available free of charge 24/7|
|Free Bike Rentals|
|BBQs and fire pits on-site with nightly s’mores|
10. The Inn at Fox Hollow Hotel
⭐️ Rating: 8.9/10.0 (222 Reviews) Price: $179 per night ?Location: 7755 Jericho Turnpike, Woodbury, NY 11797 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
Located in Woodbury, the Inn At Fox Hollow Hotel is convenient if you want to enjoy the golf courses and parks of central Long Island.
Furthermore, you’re only a short drive from historic Cove Neck.
Here, rooms are traditionally decorated with dark furnishings and Egyptian cotton lines.
Of course, the Keurig coffee makers are an epic touch while superior suites come with iMac computers.
And for a bit of extra luxury, book a room with a spa shower.
Now, the inn is one of the best romantic hotels on Long Island for foodie couples.
And that’s because you’ll start each day with a full American breakfast buffet and round out the day with a complimentary dinner served at nearby Volpe.
“Really nice people at the desk, earnestly trying to do their best. I have been here once before and likewise, it was a good stay. The food is OK and very reasonably priced. Portions are really big, especially dessert. The beer is very cold! Rooms are quite nice. I stayed in the “Royal Suite”. Really nice room, especially for long stays.”Mark (read more reviews now)
Note, this perk is only available Mondays through Thursdays and not on holidays.
However, if you stay over the weekend you’ll get a discount on your meal.
Otherwise, all units at the Inn At Fox Hollow Hotel come with basic kitchen amenities.
Outside, the Courtyard is equipped with a heated pool, hot tub, and luxury cabanas. On some evenings, live music is also offered, making this a great choice for planning Long Island romantic getaways.
|Seasonal Swimming Pool||Kitchenettes do not have stoves – only a microwave and toaster.|
|Half-board (Monday to Thursday)||Previous guests have noted issues with shower doors staying closed|
|Complimentary local shuttle (Monday to Friday)|
11. Baron’s Cove
⭐️ Rating: 8.3/10.0 (117 Reviews) Price: $191 per night ?Location: 31 W Water St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
Baron’s Cove in Sag Harbor is a waterside resort with rooms that feature either village or harbor views.
So, once you’ve parked, you can explore the many restaurants, marina, and local museums here on foot.
Now, rooms and suites at Baron’s Cove are furnished with a nautical theme.
So, furnishings have a homey and snug feel, with immaculate marble and tiled bathrooms to rinse off in after a day at the beach.
Of course, you can splurge on the Loft Suite for your romantic Long Island getaway, which comes with a scenic balcony and snuggly lounge.
“The hotel was beautiful and clean. Love the views. The bed! The staff were really nice and welcoming. Special shout out to Mohamed and Maria. I was new to the area- when it was time to get back to the city I had some trouble getting a car to take me to the station. Mohamed and Maria went above and beyond to help me. I didn’t have cash on me so I was actually driven to a bank and then the station. Generally kind and good people. Thank you so much.”Laura (read more reviews now)
Then, in the evening, enjoy a drink or meal at the property bar and restaurant, or visit the reception desk for insider tips on where to eat.
Just remember to pack your swimsuit since the backyard features a pool, sun deck, and lawn right on the banks of Sag Harbor Cove.
|Complimentary bike rentals||No breakfast available|
|Pet-friendly||Minimum stay of 2 weeks in July and August|
|Free Parking||Property restaurant is expensive|
Romantic hotels on Long Island – Budget
12. Driftwood Resort on the Ocean
⭐️ Rating: 8.3/10.0 (171 Reviews) Price: $170 per night ?Location: 2178 Montauk Highway, Montauk, NY 11954 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
For romantic hotels on Long Island on a budget, Driftwood Resort on the Ocean is the place to be since it offers cheerful studios and apartments.
All are decorated in a modern style with comfy, plush bedding and the perk of a plump couch in larger rooms.
Plus, each of these accomodations is equipped with cooking essentials. So, expect to find fridges and microwaves in basic units and fully-equipped kitchens in their one-bedroom apartments.
“We had a very nice stay. Sophie was very accommodating and Santiago was extremely helpful.”Maria (read more reviews now)
Just bear in mind that this hotel doesn’t have a restaurant or offer breakfast. So, you’ll need to factor in groceries in between meals out.
Even better, you can upgrade to one of the studios with a balcony. From here, take in views of the surrounding greenery over morning coffee or spend long evenings relaxing with a bottle of wine.
Plus, this resort has a large pool with a sun deck – available from May through early October.
And this beachside resort is also just steps from the sand, making it ideal for couples and families with kids alike.
|Free Parking||Check in isn’t until 4:00 pm|
|Quiet place||Minor hiccups with faulty television sets and dippy Wi-Fi are reported|
|Seasonal pool||No pets allowed|
|Some rooms have beach views|
|Beachside setting in western Montauk|
13. Aqualina Inn Montauk
⭐️ Rating: 9.1/10.0 (286 Reviews) Price: $200 per night ?Location: 20 South Elmwood Avenue, Montauk, NY, 11954 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
Situated in historic Montauk Village, the Aqualina Inn Montauk is only a couple of blocks from the beach and various downtown attractions.
Plus, all the essential amenities are on offer at this brand spanking new, super clean, modern motel.
After all, each unit is outfitted with a mini-fridge, microwave, and coffee-making facilities.
“The hotel was very cozy, clean and had comfortable beds. Great location for touring Montauk.”Dennis (read more reviews now)
Rooms are also comfortably furnished with ocean-inspired art on the walls that will lull you into a state of calm.
Now, for a romantic vacation, you should check out the rooms with either a balcony or a spa bath. This way, you can turn your wallet-friendly trip into a luxury getaway.
Additionally, the inn complex has a decent-sized pool with sun loungers and a couple of hammocks.
This place is also popular with cyclists and surfers, so reception can hook you up with a local rental.
And while no breakfast is provided, you’re just steps away from Montauk’s best cafes and bakeries.
|Free Parking||Pets Not Allowed|
|Super Clean||Walls are Thin|
|Beach Towels Offered||Only open from May through October|
|Heated saltwater pool (seasonal – from Labor Day through Columbus Day)|
14. Harborfront Inn
⭐️ Rating: 8.3/10.0 (165 Reviews) Price: $150 per night ?Location: 209 Front St, Greenport, NY 11944 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
Located right on Front Street, the Harborfront Inn puts you in the beating heart of Greenport.
In the style of the old waterfront boarding houses of the past, this charming inn will appeal to old souls.
In fact, this mellow hotel ticks all the boxes for a cost-effective romantic retreat on Long Island.
“This boutique Inn is perfect. You can’t find a better location to walk around Greenport. We stayed during the week which was ideal-not many crowds.”Cynthia (read more reviews now)
Plus, fuss-free modern rooms prioritize comfort with village-room options fitted with lovely large windows that catch the morning sun.
However, superior rooms come with balconies overlooking the harbor. So, just picture the scene. You and your partner sitting out in your fluffy Frette bathrobes with not a care in the world.
Heck, some rooms even come with walk-in showers, whereas others have deep, tiled bathtubs.
Then, each day you can wake up to continental breakfast before leaping in the pool.
And, when you need a break from the sun deck, you can make the most of your complimentary beach pass at the hotel’s sister property, which is only about a mile away.
|Complimentary Breakfast||Housekeeping only available if requested|
|Pet-friendly||Parking is $25.00 per day|
|Seasonal Swimming Pool||Check-in is late and at 4:00 pm|
|Small-ish pool and deck|
15. Beachcomber Resort at Montauk
⭐️ Rating: 8.6/10.0 (243 Reviews) Price: $217 per night ?Location: 727 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954 Details: Read more on booking.com now!
You can’t get much better than the Beachcomber Resort at Montauk for budget-friendly romantic hotels on Long Island.
Because this place is less than a 10-minute walk away from the beach and the restaurants of Montauk.
In fact, the superior studios and suites include balconies with sea views, where you can while away an afternoon with your OH.
Most of those balconies are also partially covered, which is handy if you run into some rain.
“I had the perfect room with a great view. It was very clean and the staff very nice to me and my family. Keep up the good work.”Stanley (read more reviews now)
Now, the resort is pretty old-fashioned in its appearance, which some travelers will appreciate more than others.
Nonetheless, interiors are comfortable and clean, with decor relfecting the seaside setting. So, think, cool blue hues and sand-colored walls.
Just come prepared with groceries since all units come with kitchen facilities. Which, is important since there’s no breakfast or restaurant on the premises.
Other hotel amenities include a fitness center and pool with sun loungers and umbrellas. But, the beach is also literally right there so just remember your sunscreen.
|Great Location||Decor/facilities are a but outdated|
|Swimming Pool||No pets|
|Free Parking||No breakfast|
|Some Rooms Offer Sea Views|
Most Romantic Hotels on Long Island FAQ
What are the Best Romantic Hotels in Long Island?
The best romantic hotels in Long Island are:
- Aqualina Inn Montauk (9.1/10.0 with 286 Reviews)
- The Menhaden Hotel (9.4/10.0 with 104 reviews)
- Inn at Fox Hollow Hotel (8.9/10.0 with 222 Reviews)
Do Any Romantic Hotels in Long Island Have a Spa On-Site?
Romantic hotels on Long Island that have a spa on-site include:
- Inn at Fox Hollow Hotel (8.9/10.0 with 222 Reviews)
- The Quogue Club (9.1/10.0 with 28 Reviews)
- Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa (7.8/10.0 with 193 Reviews)
Map of the Most Romantic Hotels on Long island
Short on time? ⏰ Then book a room at The Menhaden Hotel. The staff is lovely and the rooftop is incredible, making this the best and most romantic hotel on Long Island.?